What if matching stress tensors across dual descriptions requires *non-local* state assignments that still respect relativistic locality?

# Matching Stress Tensors Across Dual Descriptions: Non-locality and Relativistic Causality

Your question sits at a deep junction: can two mathematically equivalent descriptions of gravity or quantum fields assign stress-energy tensors in ways that appear non-local, yet remain compatible with relativistic causality? The archive suggests the answer is subtle and context-dependent.

The Stress Tensor as Relational Information

Start with a foundational reframing. In quantum gravity with reference frames, the stress-energy tensor need not be a purely local geometric object—it encodes *relational information* between the physical system and a local observer or frame [AG-2025.05-865]. When you shift between dual descriptions (say, from a particle picture to a field picture, or from one reference frame to another), you're not moving the stress tensor through spacetime; you're changing which correlations the metric or connection encodes. Under a suitable constraint on conditional entropy, this relational picture recovers the full nonlinear Einstein equation [AG-2025.05-865]—meaning the apparent non-locality is a feature of the description, not a violation of physics.

Field-Theoretic Locality: State Assignment Matters

Here's where it gets technical but crucial: the choice of how you assign quantum states to regions determines whether you see locality or not [AG-2024.12-903].

The paper examines two methods in quantum field theory:

1. Field wave functionals (assigning states based on field configurations): This method yields a *local* theory.

2. Fock space particle wave functions (assigning states in terms of particle creation operators): This leads to either non-locality *or* the inability to assign states to regions at all, depending on which creation operators you choose [AG-2024.12-903].

This is not a bug—it's evidence that state assignments are not observer-independent. When you switch between dual descriptions (field vs. particle), you switch which state-assignment scheme applies, and apparent non-locality in one picture can reflect the relational nature of quantum observables.

Preserving Causality Across Correlated Updates

If your dual descriptions involve measurements or state updates in different regions, the archive offers a modern solution: the polyperspective formalism [AG-2025.06-596].

Standard relativistic state updates along future light-cones preserve causality but break correlations between causally disconnected regions. The polyperspective method extends multipartite states to encode subsystem-specific *contextual information*, ensuring that:

• State updates are causally consistent and covariant
• Multipartite correlations are preserved across the update
• Conservation laws are respected

This means you can have stress-tensor assignments that look non-local within one description yet remain causal in the combined relativistic framework [AG-2025.06-596].

A Concrete Example: Quantum Superposition and Effective Forces

The bitensorial approach to quantum gravity illustrates why non-local state assignments might be necessary [AG-2025.12-343]. When the gravitational source is in a quantum superposition, the model predicts a novel non-conservative effective force on test particles. This force depends on the velocity of the probe and arises from treating the connection as an independent field that responds to quantum correlations. The stress-energy tensor for such a system cannot be assigned locally in the classical sense; it requires encoding the superposition's non-local coherences [AG-2025.12-343].

The Rigorous Field-Theory Picture

At the most rigorous level, the stress-energy-momentum tensor in quantum field theory should be constructed from smeared local fields using positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs) on spacelike hypersurfaces [AG-2026.04-631]. These satisfy a relativistic causality condition that excludes superluminal propagation of detection probabilities, even though the tensor itself may encode correlations with observers at different points in spacetime [AG-2026.04-631]. The Reeh-Schlieder theorem implies the normally ordered stress tensor is not strictly positive on the full Fock space; quantum energy inequalities provide lower bounds that control deviations [AG-2026.04-631], meaning apparent "violations" of positivity are actually finite and controlled.

Bottom Line

Non-local state assignments can be compatible with relativistic locality if they reflect relational information between systems and reference frames, rather than genuine action-at-a-distance. The choice of dual description (particle vs. field, one frame vs. another) determines which state-assignment scheme applies, and polyperspective methods can ensure causally consistent updates across them. The stress tensor, in this view, is not a fixed local object to be "matched"—it encodes which observer or reference frame is doing the matching.