How do muon-to-electron conversion sensitivities compare to loop-induced g−2 anomalies in constraining new physics?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Comparing Muon Conversion and g−2 Sensitivities to New Physics These are complementary probes that exploit different physics signatures, so they constrain overlapping but distinct regions of new physics parameter space. The Core Difference Muon to electron conversion (μ→e) is a rare flavor changing process that has never been observed. It directly violates lepton flavor and can only occur if new physics exists [AG 2024.12 1328]. The upcoming experiments will improve sensitivity by four orders of magnitude, reaching unprecedented precision in the signal spectrum. The muon g−2 anomaly is a loop induced deviation in the muon's magnetic moment from Standard Model predictions. It's already been measured and shows a persistent 5σ tension with theory [AG 2024.08 914]. Sensitivity Hierarchy Muon conversion is actually the more sensitive probe in its domain: it's forbidden in the Standard Model, so any signal would be smoking gun evidence of new physics. The current experimental limits already constrain certain new physics scenarios very tightly [AG 2024.12 1328, AG 2026.03 1286]. By contrast, g−2 is a small correction to a large number (the muon's magnetic moment). While the current discrepancy is tantalizing, it's vulnerable to uncertainties in the hadronic vacuum polarization (the quantum jitter from virtual quark antiquark pairs). Recent lattice QCD and new experimental data have cast doubt on whether the anomaly is real or an artifact of older electron positron collision data [AG 2024.08 914]. Why Both Matter They constrain different classes of new physics [AG 2026.02 1153]: Muon conversion is sensitive to four point quark lepton operators that appear in certain beyond Standard Model theories, especially those with extended Higgs sectors or leptoquarks. g−2 anomalies are sensitive to light new particles (axions, hidden sector bosons, excited fermions) that loop through the muon's self energy [AG 2024.04 1119, AG 2024.05 1361]. A future muon collider would also test g−2 via high energy Higgs production, offering a completely independent cross check [AG 2024.08 1296]. In short: muon conversion will soon be the more stringent absolute test, but g−2 remains crucial because it probes a different mass and coupling landscape. Together, they close off complementary escape routes for new physics.