Antigravity Q&A
If quirks carry fractional charge, would their radius of curvature still follow classical equations?
Answered by claude-haiku-4-5 · 2 May 2026
Answer
Your question touches on something subtle: whether the classical equations of motion (which describe how charged particles curve through space in magnetic fields) would still hold for quarks, which carry fractional electric charges like ±1/3 or ±2/3 of the electron charge.
The short answer is: yes, the radius of curvature formula would still apply, but with important caveats about what "radius" means at quantum scales.
Why the classical formula still works
The radius of curvature for a charged particle in a magnetic field depends only on the particle's momentum and the strength of the magnetic force—it doesn't care about the absolute magnitude of the charge. The standard formula, r = p / (qB) (where p is momentum, q is charge, and B is magnetic field strength), scales linearly with charge. A quark with charge q = e/3 would simply follow a path with radius one-third that of an electron under the same conditions. The geometry itself—the classical trajectory—remains valid.
This assumes the particle behaves as a point-like object, which brings us to the real complication.
The quantum catch
At the scales where quarks exist, the notion of a sharp "radius of curvature" becomes fuzzy. Quarks are confined inside hadrons and cannot be observed in isolation, so the question of their individual trajectories doesn't have a straightforward experimental answer. More fundamentally, quantum mechanics tells us that a particle's position isn't sharply defined—it has a wave function spread over a region.
The provided preprints address related but somewhat different questions: one explores how the effective radius of a point charge can be made arbitrarily small in modified electrodynamics [AG-2025.10-820], and another proposes a geometric model where an electron's charge center traces a fourth-order curve [AG-2026.01-028]. Neither directly addresses quark motion in magnetic fields, so I cannot cite specific support for how fractional charge affects the curvature of confined quarks.
Sources · 8
- 57%physics.class-phThe Effective Radius of an Electric Point Charge in Nonlinear ElectrodynamicsAG-2025.10-820
- 56%physics.gen-phIs it possible to describe an electron by the evolution of a single point?AG-2026.01-028
- 55%physics.opticsGeometry-Induced Vacuum Polarization and Mode Shifts in Maxwell-Klein-Gordon TheoryAG-2025.12-145
- 54%hep-thLoop Quantum Gravity effects on electromagnetic properties of charged leptonsAG-2024.03-856
- 53%hep-phQuantum stresses in the hydrogen atomAG-2024.12-1434
- 53%quant-phSemi-Classical Electrodynamics and the Casimir EffectAG-2024.02-700
- 53%physics.class-phRadiation-Reaction on the Straight-Line Motion of a Point Charge accelerated by a constant applied Electric Field in an Electromagnetic Bopp-Landé-Thomas-Podolsky vacuumAG-2025.06-349
- 53%hep-thCoulomb Potential in Podolsky-Carroll-Field-Jackiw ElectrodynamicsAG-2026.04-848
Keep exploring
This is a research aid — not a peer review. Verify sources before citing.