Would multipole moment differences between Tomimatsu–Sato and Kerr affect gravitational wave ringdown signals?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Multipole Moments, Tomimatsu–Sato, and Ringdown Yes, multipole moment differences between Tomimatsu–Sato and Kerr black holes would affect ringdown signals in principle—but detecting those differences is challenging. The Core Physics A Kerr black hole is uniquely specified by just two parameters: mass and spin. All of its multipole moments (quadrupole, octupole, and higher) are then completely determined [AG 2026.04 266]. The Tomimatsu–Sato solution is a different family of rotating black hole solutions in general relativity that possess extra "hairs"—additional parameters beyond mass and spin. These extra parameters alter the multipole moment structure. Since ringdown is essentially the merger remnant's geometry ringing like a bell, and that geometry depends on all the multipole moments, a black hole with different moments would emit quasinormal modes (the characteristic frequencies and decay rates) that differ from the Kerr prediction [AG 2024.12 266]. In particular, the ringdown encodes information about the entire spacetime geometry of the merger remnant, not just its inspiral [AG 2025.03 451]. Why This Matters Testing whether nature produces Kerr black holes or alternatives is one of the central questions in gravitational wave astronomy. Ringdown observations provide a direct probe: if you measure the frequencies and damping times of the oscillations, you can infer the mass and spin of the remnant and then check whether all the multipole moments match the Kerr prediction. The Observational Challenge Current observations have placed constraints on spin induced quadrupole moment deviations using the inspiral phase [AG 2026.04 266], and ringdown based tests of spacetime symmetries have begun using events like GW150914 [AG 2024.12 266]. However, ringdown models themselves have accuracy limitations—they work reliably only in the late time stationary regime, and higher order modes remain difficult to extract cleanly from data [AG 2025.11 086]. A specific prediction: Tomimatsu–Sato black holes would show deviations most clearly in the higher multipole moments (octupole and beyond), which couple to higher order harmonic modes in the gravitational wave signal. These are weaker and noisier than the dominant quadrupole modes, making them harder to detect with current instruments but potentially accessible to next generation detectors like LISA. None of these preprints directly address Tomimatsu–Sato ringdown signatures; they focus on testing the Kerr hypothesis more generally and on multipole moment tests via other pathways.