Could coarse-graining a microscopically discrete horizon produce Tsallis non-extensivity without long-range interactions?

Your question is technically sophisticated and sits right at the intersection of quantum gravity and statistical mechanics. Let me address what the archive says about this.

The short answer: yes, there's a plausible mechanism, but the archive suggests it's more subtle than a simple coarse-graining story.

The core mechanism

When you coarse-grain a microscopically discrete horizon—imagine summing over many Planck-scale degrees of freedom to get an effective macroscopic description—you naturally encounter correlations between the remaining degrees of freedom. These correlations can mimic long-range interactions in the coarse-grained theory *even if the microscopic interactions are short-ranged*. This is the key insight: [AG-2026.02-262] establishes "a relationship between the parameter describing the microscopic structure of quantum foam and the parameter associated with macroscopic nonextensive effects," suggesting that horizon discreteness and Tsallis non-extensivity are two sides of the same coin.

More concretely, [AG-2024.08-391] shows that Tsallis entropy (characterized by the non-additivity index δ) naturally emerges from modified gravity theories—specifically, when the gravitational Lagrangian is generalized as $\mathcal{L} \propto R^{1+ε}$ where ε = δ − 1 quantifies deviations from general relativity. This suggests the non-extensivity is baked into the geometry itself, not merely a statistical artifact of coarse-graining.

The thermodynamic signature

The reason this matters: [AG-2025.02-415] demonstrates that black hole entropy gets modified by non-extensivity and that "the black hole can be stabilized due to the non-extensivity," potentially resolving thermodynamic instabilities. This is testable—the non-extensive parameter is constrained by observations.

An important caveat

However, [AG-2025.09-661] raises a red flag: when Tsallis cosmology is embedded in realistic scenarios (horizon thermodynamics, holographic frameworks), "even mild departures from δ = 1 lead to pathological behavior in the effective dark energy sector." This suggests that while coarse-graining *can* produce Tsallis statistics, the real universe may not tolerate the resulting dynamics unless δ is extremely close to 1 (within $|1 - δ| \lesssim 10^{-3}$). In other words, the mechanism works in principle, but nature seems to have tuned it very finely.

On long-range interactions

[AG-2024.09-007] clarifies an important point: "gravitational systems admit long-range interactions which usually lead to a break of the standard additivity rule." So strictly speaking, horizons *are* long-range systems. Your question asks whether you can avoid this—but the archive suggests that once you've coarse-grained a quantum-gravitational horizon, you've necessarily created an effective long-range structure, even if the underlying interactions were local.